Comic Book
Awards Almanac

American Awards

Comic Buyer's Guide Fan Awards
Info Page
1982 (Not available)
1983 (Not available)
1984 (Not available)
1985 (Not available)
1986 (Top 10 only)
1987 (Information not available)
1988 (Information not available)
1989 (Partial)
1990 (Partial)
1991 (Not available)
1992 (Partial)
1993 (Partial)
1994 (Not available)
1995 (Winners only)
1996 (1997)
1997 (1998)
1998 (1999)
1999 (2000)
2000 (2001)
2001 (2002)
2002 (2003)
2003 (2004)
Summary of winners

Non-U.S. Awards
Other Awards
Administrivia

Main Page

1986 Comics Buyers Guide Fan Awards

(All comics with a 1986 cover date were eligible, which explains the presence of some 1985 miniseries or stories that ran into 1986. Vote tallies are in [brackets], and only listed the top 10 in each category are listed.)

FAVORITE COMIC BOOK STORY
1. Batman: The Dark Knight 1-4 [533]
2. Daredevil 227-233 [236]
3. Watchmen [188]
4. Superman 423/Action 583 ("What ever happened to the Man of Tomorrow?")
        [139]
5. X-Men 210-213/X-Factor 9-11/Thor 373/New Mutants 46/Power Pack 27/
        Daredevil 238 (Mutant Massacre) [136]
6. Swamp Thing 53 (Swamp Thing invades Gotham City) [115]
7. Man of Steel 1-6 [101]
8. Crisis on Infinite Earths [58]
9. Batman 400 [52]
10. New Mutants 45 [53]

FAVORITE LIMITED COMIC BOOK SERIES
1. Batman: the Dark Knight [944]
2. Watchmen [660]
3. Man of Steel [407]
4. Legends [224]
5. Elektra: Assassin [118]
6. Mage [76]
6. Punisher [76]
8. Crisis on Infinite Earths [61]
9. Aquaman [48]
10. The Shadow [34]

FAVORITE COLORIST
1. Lynn Varley [622]
2. Tom Ziuko [273]
3. Tatjana Wood [266]
4. Glynis Oliver [212]
5. Adrienne Roy [186]
6. Carl Gafford [142]
7. Christie Max Scheele [127]
8. Matt Wagner [103]
9. John Higgins [96]
10. Les Dorscheid [86]

FAVORITE COVER ARTIST
1. George Perez [444]
2. Bill Sienkiewicz [416]
3. Arthur Adams [381]
4. John Byrne [294]
5. Dave Stevens [188]
6. Frank Miller [106]
7. Walter Simonson [86]
8. Mike Zeck [72]
9. Barry Windsor-Smith [66]
10. Steve Lightle [64]

FAVORITE GRAPHIC NOVEL (includes new and reprint)
1. Daredevil: Love and War [527]
2. The Dark Knight [478]
3. Amazing Spider-Man: Hooky [197]
4. Grendel: Devil by the Deed [157]
5. Robotech the Graphic Novel, Genesis: Robotech [124]
6. Alien Legion: A Grey Day to Die [81]
7. Dracula: A Symphony in Moonlight and Murder [79]
8. Demon with a Glass Hand [77]
9. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles [70]
10. Time2: the Epiphany [64]

FAVORITE WRITER
1. Alan Moore [876]
2. Frank Miller [796]
3. Chris Claremont [266]
4. John Byrne [176]
5. Marv Wolfman [164]
6. Roy and Dann Thomas [89]
7. Mike Baron [63]
8. Matt Wagner [58]
9. Louise Simonson [57]
10. Paul Levitz [56]

FAVORITE LETTERER
1. John Costanza [733]
2. Tom Orzechowski [350]
3. Ken Bruzenak [281]
4. John Workman [271]
5. Jim Novak [124]
6. Joe Rosen [117]
7. Bob Lappan [95]
8. Todd Klein [84]
9. Bob Pinaha [79]
10. Dave Gibbons [75]

FAVORITE COMIC BOOK (title)
1. Swamp Thing [395]
2. Uncanny X-Men [356]
3. Batman [127]
4. Legion of Super-Heroes/Tales of the LSH [116]
5. Superman [101]
6. New Teen Titans/Tales of the Teen Titans [93]
7. X-Factor [89]
8. Daredevil [82]
9. Avengers [79]
10. Watchmen [73]

FAVORITE CHARACTER
1. Batman [680]
2. Wolverine [287]
3. Superman [178]
4. Rorschach (Watchmen) [136]
5. Spider-Man [122]
6. Swamp Thing [96]
7. 'Mazing Man [49]
8. Daredevil [46]
9. Cerebus [44]
10. Groo [44]

FAVORITE INKER
1. Terry Austin [724]
2. Karl Kesel [348]
3. Klaus Janson [231]
4. Dick Giordano [188]
5. Tom Palmer [94]
6. Jerry Ordway [90]
7. John Totleben [84]
8. Mike DeCarlo [66]
8. Bruce D. Patterson [66]
10. Romeo Tanghal [65]

FAVORITE PENCILLER
1. John Byrne [647]
2. George Perez [510]
3. Arthur Adams [246]
4. Frank Miller [244]
5. Bill Sienkiewicz [114]
6. Steve Rude [112]
7. David Mazzuchelli [85]
8. Dave Gibbons [67]
9. Todd McFarlane [60]
10. Alan Davis [59]

FAVORITE DIRECT-SALES ONLY TITLE (Phil Seuling Award)
1. Watchmen [272]
2. New Teen Titans [238]
3. Infinity Inc. [183]
4. Power Pack [159]
5. Batman: the Dark Knight [151]
6. Legion of Super-Heroes [149]
7. Cerebus [92]
8. Nexus [85]
9. Vigilante [71]
10. Mage [62]

FAVORITE PUBLICATION ABOUT COMICS
1. Amazing Heroes [1022]
2. Comics Journal [245]
3. Marvel Age [243]
4. Comics Feature [224]
5. Comics Interview [100]
6. Comic Book Price Guide [79]
7. Four Color Magazine [61]
8. Comics Collector [43]
9. DC Releases [30]
10. 

FAVORITE EDITOR
1. Denny O'Neil [389]
2. Mark Gruenwald [296]
3. Karen Berger [253]
4. Marv Wolfman [217]
5. Ann Nocenti [210]
6. Mike Gold [164]
7. Jim Shooter [163]
8. Andy Helfer [151]
9. Dick Giordano [131]
10. Roy Thomas [113]

A look at who voted:
Most common age: 15
Age that had same number above and below it: 18
Arithmetical average: 20.7
Gender: Males: 3017
        Females: 191
        No answer: 166